Collectible Appraisals
How grading scales, version and condition set the price of cards, comics, coins and other collectibles, how to spot copies, and how to check prices.
Grading: the number that sets the price
For many collectibles, a professional grade is the biggest thing that moves the price. Each hobby has its own scale, so learn the one for what you collect.
- Comic books: CGC uses a 10-point scale, from 0.5 (Poor) to 10 (Gem Mint). Small steps near the top, such as 9.4 to 9.8, can change the price a lot.
- Coins: NGC and other coin graders use a 70-point scale, from 1 (Poor) to 70 (perfect). Coins graded 60 and above are "Mint State," which means they were never used as money.
- Trading cards: PSA, CGC Cards and Beckett grade cards on a 1-to-10 scale. Corners, edges, surface and centering all count.
Grading costs money and takes time. It usually only makes sense when an item is already valuable and in very good shape. If a card or comic has a crease or a stain you can see, a high grade is unlikely.
Copies and fakes
A federal law, the Hobby Protection Act, says copies of coins and other money-like items must be marked with the word "COPY." Copies of political buttons and posters must show the year they were made. The Federal Trade Commission's rules for this are in 16 CFR Part 304. If a "rare coin" has COPY stamped on it, it is a replica, not the real thing. For cards, compare the print, the font, the card stock and the holo pattern with a card you know is real.
Keep collectibles in good shape
- Store cards in sleeves and top loaders, and comics in bags with backing boards.
- Keep everything flat, dry, cool and out of sunlight.
- Handle coins by the edges. Never clean a coin; cleaning can lower its value.
- Keep original boxes, papers and tags. Buyers pay more for complete items.
How to check a price
Find the exact version: year, set, number, printing and grade. Then look at recent sold prices for that same version. Prices for graded items are often listed by grade, so compare yours only with items at the same grade. A photo scan can help name the item, but the version and grade are what set the price.
Read next
- How to value Pokémon cards
- How to spot fake Pokémon cards
- How much is my vinyl record worth?
- Vintage toys worth money
- How to check if a collectible is valuable
Sources
Frequently asked questions
How do I find out what my baseball cards are worth?
Scan the card with a clear photo showing player, year and set. ValU estimates a range from recent sold cards. Condition and grading (PSA, BGS, SGC) have a big effect on value.
How do I know if my Pokémon cards are valuable?
Check the set symbol, card number, rarity and whether it is a holo or first edition. Scan it with ValU for an estimated sold-price range, and look closely for creases or whitening, which lower the value.
Are my vinyl records worth anything?
It depends on the pressing, not just the album. Matrix numbers in the run-out groove and the label identify the pressing. ValU gives an estimate; Discogs is the best place to confirm the exact pressing.
Should I get a collectible graded?
Grading usually only makes sense for items likely worth well above the grading fee, in very good condition. Use ValU's estimate to decide whether it's worth the cost.
Is the value ValU shows exact?
No. ValU gives an estimated price range based on comparable sold listings, plus a confidence score. The real price depends on condition, demand and where you sell, so treat it as a starting point, not a guarantee.
Is ValU really free?
ValU is free to start, with no subscription. Usage limits can apply. The site is supported by ads.